← BACK TO GRAVEYARD

IdeaBench

Discover your next million-dollar idea

PEAK MRR
$0
TOTAL USERS
0
RAISED
$0
DURATION
Aug 2025
Sep 2025
AUTHORVulcanWMsolo developer building and shipping ideas fast, learning by failing
REASON FOR DEATHBetter Alternatives Exist
TECH STACK
Next.jsStripe

THE IDEA

The goal was to help founders skip brainstorming by giving them a curated list of startup ideas with analysis on monetisation potential, competition, and ease of build. Instead of staring at a blank page, users could pick an idea and start building immediately.

WHAT WENT WRONG

The problem wasn’t demand for ideas, it was differentiation. Founders already had access to idea lists, newsletters, twitter threads, reddit, and free tools that did roughly the same thing. IdeaBench didn’t feel meaningfully better than what already existed, especially not enough to justify paying. Most users browsed the preview, nodded, and left.

LESSONS LEARNED

01

Competition matters more than idea quality

02

People rarely pay for information they believe they can get for free

03

A landing page with interest is not the same as willingness to pay

04

Distribution is a product, not an afterthought

WHAT'S NEXT

Moving away from generic idea validation tools and focusing on products with built-in distribution or clear pain felt daily. Next time, I’ll test pricing and differentiation before writing the full product.

LEARN FROM THIS FAILURE

Fork the code, read through the mistakes, and build something better. That's what this is all about.